The Rounds Journal · Management & leadership
Difficult conversations in healthcare teams: prepare, listen and agree a next step
Prepare for a difficult conversation with a colleague: describe the issue, hear their perspective and agree what happens next.
A difficult conversation becomes easier to prepare when you separate what you observed, why it matters and what decision is needed. That does not remove the discomfort. It gives both people something specific to discuss rather than a judgment about someone’s character.
Choose the right setting and route
For a routine management issue, arrange a private conversation and enough time to listen. An immediate safety concern, safeguarding issue or serious misconduct may need a different escalation route. Follow your organization’s procedures and seek appropriate support rather than trying to resolve everything through informal coaching.
Write down observations before interpretations
Consider an illustrative scheduling problem: a handover document has arrived after the agreed time on several occasions. Record the dates and the agreed expectation. “You do not care about the team” is an interpretation; it does not explain the behavior that needs to change.
Before the meeting, ask whether the expectation was clear, whether the person had the information and authority to meet it, and whether the workload made it realistic. These questions help you investigate the issue without deciding the explanation in advance.
Structure the opening
AHRQ’s TeamSTEPPS includes SBAR: situation, background, assessment and recommendation or request. It can help organize an issue so the listener understands what you are asking. It is a communication aid, not a substitute for clinical escalation or an organization’s employee procedures.
- Situation: identify the specific issue you need to discuss.
- Background: explain the relevant agreement or context.
- Assessment: describe the effect you have observed and what remains uncertain.
- Request: ask for their perspective and propose a next step.
Listen for a problem you can solve together
Ask what made the expectation difficult to meet. You may learn that two teams use different cut-off times, a template is unavailable or approval arrives too late. You may also discover that the expectation is understood but not being followed. The response should depend on what the conversation establishes.
Repeat back the issue in plain language. Check your understanding before moving to a solution. If the conversation becomes heated, a pause and a clear time to resume may be more useful than trying to win the point.
Agree an observable next step
“Communicate better” is hard to review. A clearer agreement identifies the action, owner and review date: use the agreed template by the cut-off, raise an expected delay through the agreed channel, and review whether the arrangement worked after a defined period. Make a proportionate record in the approved system.
Check whether the new arrangement creates another problem for the person or the service. If the cause is a process problem, the follow-up may require another team’s participation rather than an individual promise.
For the wider responsibility change, read moving from clinical work into management. For development options, compare healthcare management study.
Reflect on the skills you want to develop →
Sources and scope
AHRQ TeamSTEPPS SBAR communication tool
Sources checked 15 November 2026. Examples and planning exercises are editorial guidance, not reported outcomes or individual admission decisions. Confirm current requirements directly before applying.
Leave the conversation with an agreement you can check
Consider a fictional team where routine equipment requests keep being returned because the location field is blank. The person sending requests believes the location is obvious, while the receiving team covers several sites. Start by bringing two or three examples with the details needed to discuss the process. Ask each side to explain what they see when a request arrives and which information they need to act. This can reveal that the form reaches each team in a different view or that it does not clearly show which location is expected.
Make the agreement specific: the requestor will give a location in an agreed format, the receiver will use one clear route to ask for missing information, and both teams will review returned requests after a short trial. Name the person responsible for keeping track. Ask that person to repeat the new arrangement before everyone leaves the meeting. A written recap is useful when people work different shifts or when one team could not attend.
Choose a response for the kind of disagreement you have
If colleagues disagree about what happened, compare the timeline against records you can use legitimately. If they agree on the facts but want different outcomes, identify what each is trying to protect. One person may want a faster turnaround while another needs enough information to avoid repeated work. The agreement can address both if it sets a clear minimum for a complete request and gives everyone a way to flag exceptions.
If the concern involves unsafe practice, discrimination or a breach of policy, follow the organisation’s reporting process and seek advice from the responsible lead. For an ordinary process disagreement, agree a review date and what you will check. For example, count how many requests come back for missing information and ask whether the revised process added work for anyone. If it did, look together at which part of the agreement needs adjusting.
After the review, record the decision and tell the people it affects, including staff on other shifts. This closes the loop and lets the next conversation start with observable evidence.